Where to Find a Nanny: Every Channel Compared Honestly

Last updated September 28, 2026

Heads-up: product links on this page are plain links to retailers. We may earn a commission from some in the future, at no cost to you — see our affiliate disclosure for details.

There are five ways to find a nanny, and the right one depends almost entirely on two variables: how fast you need someone, and how much screening risk you’re willing to carry yourself. This page compares every channel on cost, speed, candidate quality, and effort — and tells you, plainly, which of these channels has any financial relationship with this site.

Our financial relationships, stated up front

Of all the channels below, exactly one has a verified publisher affiliate program: Sittercity, which pays publishers per new paid family membership and new sitter registration. The rates aren’t publicly disclosed — they’re set in a post-application insertion order — but the program exists and is real.

Care.com, UrbanSitter, Bambino, Wyndy, Jovie, Nanny Lane, Angi, TaskRabbit, and traditional nanny agencies have no publisher affiliate programs we could verify. UrbanSitter, Bambino, and Angi offer customer referral credits (typically $10–$30 off for both sides) — that’s a discount for you, not a commission for us. Traditional agencies are single-market, placement-fee businesses that don’t syndicate payouts to publishers. Au pair agencies offer customer referral credits, not publisher commissions.

We’re telling you this because the standard suspicion — “they’re recommending whatever pays them” — doesn’t apply here. When we say Care.com is the fastest option for most families, we earn nothing from saying it.

The five channels

1. Large platforms: Care.com and Sittercity

Cost: Platform memberships typically run in the low hundreds per year (both operate on tiered membership plans; check current pricing — it changes). Background checks are usually an add-on or a premium tier, not included in the base membership. Label all platform pricing as “check current plans” — it moves.

How it works: Post a job, browse caregiver profiles, message candidates, run the platform’s background check option, interview, hire. You are the recruiter, the screener, and the HR department.

Speed: Fastest channel to first candidate — often same-day responses in major metros.

Candidate quality: The widest pool, which means the widest variance. You’ll see experienced career nannies and people who signed up yesterday. The platform does not meaningfully curate.

Effort: Highest. Expect to review dozens of profiles, conduct your own interviews, run your own reference checks, and manage all paperwork.

Best for: Families who need someone soon, are comfortable interviewing and screening, and want maximum choice. Full-time and part-time.

The catch: A platform background check is a starting point, not a vetting process. See is a Care.com background check enough? — the short answer is no, and you need an independent screening stack on top.

2. Traditional nanny agencies

Cost: Placement fees typically run 10–20% of the nanny’s first-year annual compensation, or a flat $2,000–$5,000 — these are typical ranges, not verified quotes; every agency prices differently and most won’t publish fees. On a $45,000/year nanny, expect roughly $4,500–$9,000. Some agencies charge a separate registration or search-retainer fee.

How it works: The agency interviews you, sources and pre-screens candidates, presents 3–5 finalists, and often helps with the work agreement and payroll setup. Many offer a replacement guarantee (typically 3–12 months: if the placement fails, they re-run the search).

Speed: Slower — 2–6 weeks is typical for a curated search.

Candidate quality: Highest average, because the agency’s reputation depends on it. Agencies tend to represent career nannies with verifiable histories.

Effort: Lowest. The agency does the sourcing and first-round screening; you interview finalists.

Best for: First-time employers, families with complex needs (multiples, special needs, unusual schedules), and anyone who’d rather pay than project-manage a search.

The catch: The fee is real money, and the agency’s incentive ends at placement. You still need your own work agreement and payroll compliance — the agency is a matchmaker, not your HR department after day one.

3. Referrals and word of mouth

Cost: Free.

How it works: Ask parent friends, school communities, neighborhood groups, your pediatrician’s bulletin board. The highest-trust channel in existence: a nanny who thrived with a family you know, for children you can observe, is worth more than any background check.

Speed: Unpredictable — instant if your network delivers, infinite if it doesn’t.

Candidate quality: Highest trust per candidate, smallest pool.

Effort: Low on screening (the reference is the family you know), moderate on logistics.

Best for: Everyone, as a parallel channel. Even if you’re running a platform search, tell your network. The best placements often come from a nanny whose current family is aging out of full-time care.

The catch: A warm referral is not a substitute for a background check and a written agreement. Families skip paperwork with referred nannies more than any other channel, and referred arrangements go sideways at the same rate as cold ones when there’s no contract. Run the same vetting stack and sign the same work agreement.

4. Direct hire: your own job post

Cost: Free to a few hundred dollars (local parent-group posts are free; a listing on a niche job board may charge).

How it works: Write the job post yourself — schedule, pay range, duties, start date — and distribute it through school listservs, neighborhood forums, community boards, and local college job boards (early-childhood education programs are a strong source for part-time and after-school care).

Speed: Moderate. Response quality depends entirely on how well you write the post.

Candidate quality: Surprisingly good for part-time and after-school roles; thinner for full-time career nannies, who tend to work through agencies or platforms.

Effort: High — you write the post, field responses, and screen from scratch.

Best for: Part-time, after-school, and summer positions; families in tight-knit communities with strong local networks.

5. Au pair agencies (the adjacent option)

Not a nanny channel, but families cross-shop it: a young person (typically 18–26) from abroad provides up to 45 hours/week of childcare in exchange for room, board, and a stipend, through a State Department–designated sponsor agency. Covered in depth in our nanny vs. daycare vs. au pair comparison. Agencies offer customer referral credits (typically a few hundred dollars), not publisher commissions — so again, no affiliate angle here.

The cost table

All figures are typical ranges, not verified quotes. Platform and agency pricing changes; confirm current pricing before budgeting.

Which channel fits which family

• Need someone in two weeks, full-time, standard schedule: Platform search (Care.com or Sittercity) run aggressively, in parallel with telling your network.
• First nanny, or complex needs (twins, special needs, 60-hour weeks): Traditional agency. The fee buys expertise you don’t have yet.
• After-school or part-time: Direct hire through school and neighborhood networks. Career nannies often don’t want 15-hour weeks; students and teachers do.
• Budget is the binding constraint: Referrals + direct hire + platform search, all three, with you doing the screening work. The money you save is paid in your time.
• Cultural exchange matters and you have a spare bedroom: Au pair program — different economics, different tradeoffs, covered here.

The decision most families get wrong

The mistake isn’t picking the wrong channel — it’s picking a low-effort channel and then skipping the high-effort parts. An agency placement still needs a work agreement. A referred nanny still needs an independent background check. A platform hire still needs payroll compliance. The channel finds the person; the employer work — vetting, agreement, taxes — is yours regardless.

Heads-up: product links on this page are plain links to retailers. We may earn a commission from some in the future, at no cost to you — see our affiliate disclosure for details.